The 4 Best West Hampton Restaurants close to Cutchogue

If you're traveling to one of many West Hampton restaurants from the New York hamlet of Cutchogue, you can expect to drive approximately 15 to 20 miles for your meal. While both locations are within Suffolk County, they are not by any means close to one another. The Westhampton hamlet and Westhampton Beach village areas are in fact right next to each other, and part of the infamous Long Island Hamptons seaside resort region. The hamlet of Cutchogue is located on the northeastern tip of Long Island, past the cities of Riverhead, Jamesport and Mattituck. Choose from any of these West Hampton restaurants for a delicious New York style meal.
Casa Basso Restaurant
59 Montauk Hwy.
Westhampton, NY 11977
(631) 288-1841

Approximately 20 miles from your Cutchogue bed and breakfast, you'll find the Casa Basso Restaurant. It first opened in 1928 and has been family-owned and operated ever since. As one of many West Hampton restaurants, it specializes in Italian cuisine with a touch of Mediterranean flavor. Some of the signature dishes include Osso Bucco, Minestrone soup, Pasta Primavera, spumante, London broil and rack of lamb. Casa Basso recommends making a reservation, as dining room seating does fill quickly. Casa Basso is open Tuesday through Sunday for dinner only, from 5:00 to 11:30 p.m. Visitors will love the old world ambiance of this restaurant, with its castle-like appearance and historic statues.

Tonino's Pizza
88 Riverhead Road
Westhampton Beach, NY 11978
(631) 288-5211

Open since 2000, Tonino's Pizza is a family-friendly restaurant that offers on-site dining and catering services. Tonino's serves a wide assortment of menu items daily for lunch and dinner. Some of its more popular dishes include the calzones and Strombolis, the gourmet pizza, seafood and veal. For catering services, Tonino's offers full tray servings that feed 10 to 12 people and half tray servings which are the perfect size for six to eight.

Baby Moon Restaurant
238 Montauk Hwy.
Westhampton Beach, NY
(631) 288-6350

Located about a 20-minute drive from your Cutchogue Inn, the Baby Moon Restaurant was founded in 1970 by Peter Gambino. Several years later, his brother John joined him in business, and they have provided the area of Westhampton with superb Italian cuisine and fresh seafood daily. As one of several award-winning West Hampton restaurants, the Gambino's have worked with a local nutritionist to also provide low-fat and low-carb menu items, to show they care about their customers' health. Signature dishes served here include grilled fish, veal chops, gourmet pizzas, lamb chops and various pastas. The Baby Moon also provides an extensive wine and beer list, catering and takeout services. The restaurant's hours are 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Sunday through Wednesday, and Friday and Saturday from 11 a.m. to 11 p.m. It's closed on Thursday.

Joe's American Grill
240 Montauk Hwy
Westhampton Beach NY 11978
(631) 288-3232

Joe's American Grill is a family-owned and operated restaurant that serves America's favorites, including burgers, fries, hot sandwiches, fresh seafood, pastas and more. This is one of several favorite West Hampton restaurants with both locals and visitors. Joe's provides a casual dining atmosphere that is family-friendly and caters to both couples or larger groups of patrons.